countculture

Open data and all that

MP attendance: end of term report

with 3 comments

[Note: Voting attendance is an imperfect proxy for actual attendance, as the figure may be depressed by silent abstentions (i.e. not voting in a division, rather than voting both ‘aye’ and ‘no’) and by just turning up to vote, but failing to attend the debate. However, until Parliament provides a better measure for attendance, or more transparency of MPs actions, this is the only one we have.]

It’s recess time again, and time for MPs’ end-of-term report. I’ll leave it to others to comment on how they’ve dealt with some of the genuinely momentous events since the summer recess. This post deals solely with their voting attendance record.

First off, let’s have an overall look at the overall figures for the period:

Oct-Dec 08 May 97-Jul 08
All MPs 70.2% 64.5%
Labour
74.8% 69.8%
Conservative
67.8% 61.7%
LibDem
72.2% 64.7%

The figures above are pretty self-explanatory. All parties have improved their attendance of votes, by 5 to 8 percentage points. Perhaps not surprising given the financial crisis.

Now let’s have a look at the main parties in detail, using the same histograms used before to show the distribution of the parties attendance figures. Interestingly (well, in a wonkish sort of way), the distributions are a bit more spread out than the long-term average. In part this is probably down to the shorter time period showing up variations that are hidden in longer period, but it’s interesting nevertheless to note that though all parties have improved their overall attendance figures, the number and proportion of Labour MPs who’ve voted in fewer than half the divisions has nearly tripled, from 11 MPs to 30 of them.

winter_08_session_by_party

[Note: there’s no significance to the width of the columns — the recent ones are narrower so that both can be seen on the same graph]

Finally, let’s have a look at those outliers, first, the MPs who attended divisions less than than 50% of the time:

Attended fewer than 50% of divisions Oct–Dec 08

Name Party Constituency Attendance % votes attended/possible
David Cameron Con Witney 28.6% 24/84
Robert Walter Con North Dorset 34.5% 29/84
Michael Mates Con East Hampshire 35.7% 30/84
Tim Yeo Con South Suffolk 35.7% 30/84
Michael Howard Con Folkestone & Hythe 36.9% 31/84
Peter Bottomley Con Worthing West 40.5% 34/84
Liam Fox Con Woodspring 40.5% 34/84
Julian Lewis Con New Forest East 42.9% 36/84
Caroline Spelman Con Meriden 42.9% 36/84
David Tredinnick Con Bosworth 42.9% 36/84
David Wilshire Con Spelthorne 42.9% 36/84
David Mundell Con Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale & Tweeddale 42.9% 36/84
Malcolm Rifkind Con Kensington & Chelsea 45.2% 38/84
Michael Gove Con Surrey Heath 45.2% 38/84
William Hague Con Richmond (Yorks) 46.4% 39/84
Mark Lancaster Con North East Milton Keynes 48.8% 41/84
Mark Oaten LDem Winchester 23.8% 20/84
Daniel Rogerson LDem North Cornwall 47.6% 40/84
Nicholas Clegg LDem Sheffield, Hallam 47.6% 40/84
Margaret Hodge Lab Barking 0.0% 0/84
Jessica Morden Lab Newport East 0.0% 0/84
Gordon Brown Lab Kirkcaldy & Cowdenbeath 3.6% 3/84
Kali Mountford Lab Colne Valley 14.3% 12/84
David Miliband Lab South Shields 19.0% 16/84
Khalid Mahmood Lab Birmingham, Perry Barr 21.4% 18/84
Gordon Banks Lab Ochil & Perthshire South 27.4% 23/84
Alistair Darling Lab Edinburgh South West 29.8% 25/84
Adam Ingram Lab East Kilbride, Strathaven & Lesmahagow 29.8% 25/84
Glenda Jackson Lab Hampstead & Highgate 31.0% 26/84
Mike Wood Lab Batley & Spen 32.1% 27/84
Frank Cook Lab Stockton North 33.3% 28/84
Geraldine Smith Lab Morecambe & Lunesdale 36.9% 31/84
Rudi Vis Lab Finchley & Golders Green 39.3% 33/84
Claire Curtis-Thomas Lab Crosby 40.5% 34/84
Alan Milburn Lab Darlington 40.5% 34/84
Keith Vaz Lab Leicester East 40.5% 34/84
Tom Harris Lab Glasgow South 40.5% 34/84
Doug Henderson Lab Newcastle upon Tyne North 42.9% 36/84
Denis Murphy Lab Wansbeck 42.9% 36/84
Bill Etherington Lab Sunderland North 44.0% 37/84
Kate Hoey Lab Vauxhall 45.2% 38/84
Denis MacShane Lab Rotherham 45.2% 38/84
Stuart Bell Lab Middlesbrough 46.4% 39/84
Joe Benton Lab Bootle 46.4% 39/84
Roger Godsiff Lab Birmingham, Sparkbrook & Small Heath 46.4% 39/84
Bill Rammell Lab Harlow 46.4% 39/84
John Austin Lab Erith & Thamesmead 47.6% 40/84
Caroline Flint Lab Don Valley 47.6% 40/84
Robert Marshall-Andrews Lab Medway 48.8% 41/84

No surprise that GB‘s in this list, voting in only 3 divisions (see here for the divisions he did take time out to vote on). Ditto Alistair Darling and David Cameron.

However, the rest of the list is more interesting. Some of those on the front bench, for example (e.g. Jacqui Smith, Jack Straw), surprisingly don’t make the list, i.e. they voted in at least 50% of the divisions. Ditto some of the opposition spokespeople.

But what about the backbenchers who are on the list. Possibly there’s a good reason for Margaret Hodge and Jessica Morden for failing to attend a single division — illness perhaps (though there’s nothing on either of their websites to indicate such a factor)? And what about Kali Mountford (14.3%) and Khalid Mahmood (21.4%).

If I was in their constituency, I’d like to know, particularly since they took little part in debates, either. Similarly for the low-raters for the Conservatives — Michael Mates and Tim Yeo (6 directorships!) at 35.7% each.

Now the MPs who voted more than 90% of the time:

Attended more than 90% of divisions

Name Party Constituency Attendance % votes attended/possible
George Young Con North West Hampshire 91.7% 77/84
Willie Rennie LDem Dunfermline & Fife West 90.5% 76/84
Andrew Stunell LDem Hazel Grove 95.2% 80/84
John Hemming LDem Birmingham, Yardley 97.6% 82/84
Ian Cawsey Lab Brigg & Goole 90.5% 76/84
Paul Clark Lab Gillingham 90.5% 76/84
John Cummings Lab Easington 90.5% 76/84
John Heppell Lab Nottingham East 90.5% 76/84
Fraser Kemp Lab Houghton & Washington East 90.5% 76/84
Phyllis Starkey Lab Milton Keynes South West 90.5% 76/84
David Heyes Lab Ashton-under-Lyne 90.5% 76/84
Kevan Jones Lab North Durham 90.5% 76/84
Ian Lucas Lab Wrexham 90.5% 76/84
Siân James Lab Swansea East 90.5% 76/84
Barbara Keeley Lab Worsley 90.5% 76/84
Clive Betts Lab Sheffield, Attercliffe 91.7% 77/84
Angela Eagle Lab Wallasey 91.7% 77/84
Maria Eagle Lab Liverpool, Garston 91.7% 77/84
John Healey Lab Wentworth 91.7% 77/84
Keith Hill Lab Streatham 91.7% 77/84
Alun Michael Lab Cardiff South & Penarth 91.7% 77/84
David Taylor Lab North West Leicestershire 91.7% 77/84
Natascha Engel Lab North East Derbyshire 91.7% 77/84
Shahid Malik Lab Dewsbury 91.7% 77/84
Liz Blackman Lab Erewash 92.9% 78/84
Bob Blizzard Lab Waveney 92.9% 78/84
Jeff Ennis Lab Barnsley East & Mexborough 92.9% 78/84
Fiona Mactaggart Lab Slough 92.9% 78/84
Andrew Miller Lab Ellesmere Port & Neston 92.9% 78/84
Kerry McCarthy Lab Bristol East 92.9% 78/84
Mary Creagh Lab Wakefield 92.9% 78/84
Lyn Brown Lab West Ham 92.9% 78/84
Kevin Barron Lab Rother Valley 94.0% 79/84
Janet Dean Lab Burton 94.0% 79/84
Jim Fitzpatrick Lab Poplar & Canning Town 94.0% 79/84
Mike Hall Lab Weaver Vale 94.0% 79/84
David Kidney Lab Stafford 94.0% 79/84
Shona McIsaac Lab Cleethorpes 94.0% 79/84
Judy Mallaber Lab Amber Valley 94.0% 79/84
James Plaskitt Lab Warwick & Leamington 94.0% 79/84
Nick Raynsford Lab Greenwich & Woolwich 94.0% 79/84
Angela Smith Lab Basildon 94.0% 79/84
Ann McKechin Lab Glasgow North 94.0% 79/84
Clive Efford Lab Eltham 95.2% 80/84
David Hanson Lab Delyn 95.2% 80/84
Dan Norris Lab Wansdyke 95.2% 80/84
Bill Olner Lab Nuneaton 95.2% 80/84
Stephen McCabe Lab Birmingham, Hall Green 96.4% 81/84
John Spellar Lab Warley 96.4% 81/84
Dave Watts Lab St Helens North 96.4% 81/84
Helen Goodman Lab Bishop Auckland 96.4% 81/84
Andrew Gwynne Lab Denton & Reddish 96.4% 81/84
Neil Gerrard Lab Walthamstow 97.6% 82/84
Brian Jenkins Lab Tamworth 97.6% 82/84
Helen Jones Lab Warrington North 97.6% 82/84
Thomas McAvoy Lab Rutherglen & Hamilton West 97.6% 82/84
Chris Bryant Lab Rhondda 97.6% 82/84
Chris Mole Lab Ipswich 97.6% 82/84
Diana Johnson Lab Kingston upon Hull North 97.6% 82/84
Tony Cunningham Lab Workington 98.8% 83/84
Dennis Skinner Lab Bolsover 100.0% 84/84

Some amazing figures in there. In fact, given his 100% record you wonder if the Beast of Bolsover has got a home to go to.

C.


Notes on calculations

  • The above calculations were derived from the voting record freely available from the Public Whip project, and cover the period from Oct 2008 to Dec 2008. The data can be downloaded in the form of a MySQL database, and this was used together with custom MySQL queries to generate the figures.

Written by countculture

December 31, 2008 at 7:02 pm

3 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. […] has supported Gordon Clown in only 16 of 84 divisions, a mere 19% of all opportunities to support the government. Chancellor Alistair darling is not much better, he has supported Gordo only 30% of the time (25 of […]

  2. Of the MPs you highlight Kali Mountford has been ill and just announced she is standing down at the next election for health reasons, Jessica Morden is on maternity leave and Margaret Hodge is on leave of absence to care for her extremely ill husband.

    Luke Akehurst

    January 17, 2009 at 10:57 pm

    • I wondered if there might be some reason like this, as I speculated in the article (and checked their personal websites — there was no relevant info on any of them). Do you know if there’s a similar reason for Khalid Mahmood?

      countculture

      January 18, 2009 at 9:24 am


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: